. |
October 2005 Guantánamo
Hunger Strike Exposes
U.S. Imperialism’s Torture Camp Horrors
On
Wednesday, October 5, the Center for Constitutional
Rights (CCR) sponsored a forum at New York Universtiy Law School to
publicize the United
States’ depraved policy of torturing and murdering prisoners in dozens
of
secret, remote military installations across the globe as part of its
self-styled “war on terror”. The featured speaker was James Yee, the
former
U.S. Army captain and Muslim chaplain at the American torture camp in
Guantánamo, Cuba, whom the government tried to frame as a
traitor after he passed
on complaints from the prisoners to his superior officers. Gita
Gutierrez of
the CCR reported on the spreading resistance at the “Gitmo” prison
camp, where
prisoners are waging a hunger strike protesting their imprisonment
without
charges or trial. The U.S. has tried to keep news of this from getting
out by
preventing lawyers from communicating with inmates. While the Bush
administration now admits that a dozen or so prisoners are refusing to
eat, and
that there were previous hunger strikes in 2002 and 2003, Gutierrez
reported
that hundreds of prisoners are risking their lives to
participate in the
protest. Speaking
before a packed hall, Gutierrez delivered an
electrifying report of current conditions at Guantánamo, while
stressing that
this U.S. torture camp is but one of many. The prisoners have been held
incommunicado, unprotected before their tormentors, many of them for
years,
although they have not been charged with any crimes. They are kept in
tiny
cages, whether in Camp X-Ray at “Gitmo,” as the military refers to the
base the
U.S. stole from Cuba, or in camps in Iraq, Afghanistan, Tadjikistan, or
. . .
who knows where. Gutierrez told how some are kept in specially
constructed
dungeons on aircraft carriers at sea. Still others are “rendered” –
turned over
by the U.S. to other governments notorious for torturing prisoners,
especially
Mubarak’s Egypt (see Janet Mayer, “Outsourcing Torture: The Secret
History of
America’s ‘Extraordinary Rendition’ Program,” The New Yorker,
14
February 2005). Bush and his Dr. Strangelove war secretary Rumsfeld
grotesquely
call their prisoners “detainees,” as if they are travelers unavoidably
but
temporarily detained, rather than victims of a seemingly permanent
imperialist
nightmare. The
prisoners are subject to a catalog of abuses
worthy of Hitler’s Nazis. But the U.S. imperialists don’t
need Nazi inspiration.
There was worldwide outrage in 2004 when some of the hidden truth came
out
about the Abu Ghraib and Bucca torture camps in Iraq. What took place
there was
part of a consistent policy. The U.S. used similar tactics in its
brutal war
against the Vietnamese a generation ago (recall the infamous “tiger
cages” at
Poulo Condor, a prison island inherited from the French colonial
rulers).
Moreover, many of these abuses have been practiced for decades against
the
mounting, heavily black prison population within the U.S. of over 2
million
behind bars. Now thousands of Near Easterners – men, women, even
children – are
being subjected to a series of horrific practices which, to paraphrase
1960s
black radical H. Rap Brown, are “as American as cherry pie.” These
include
beatings with fists, batons, rifle butts, metal bars, often to the
point of
permanent maiming, and sometimes death. If the
Nazis with Prussian bureaucratic thoroughness left
a detailed log of their slaughter of millions of European Jews (and
others,
including Communists, Slavs, Roma, homosexuals) in the Holocaust, the
practices
of the U.S. torture archipelago are documented in legalese in a string
of White
House and Department of Justice memos. Approved torture techniques
included:
mock executions, being kicked while manacled, dog attacks, total
isolation,
sensory deprivation, sleep deprivation, forced nudity, cultural and
sexual
humiliation, being forced to stand or sit in positions causing
excruciating
pain, being beaten for moving, electric shock, filthy food, dirty
water,
extremes of heat and cold, dehydration, being screamed at and cursed,
forced to
imitate animals, being anally penetrated with batons, and more. A
favorite of
the torturers at the Pentagon and CIA is the technique of simulated and
sometimes
actual drowning (cynically called “waterboarding” as if it is some kind
of
sport). The
abuses are seemingly endless, and have been
investigated by a number of groups. Physicians for Human Rights (PHR)
has
placed a great deal of documentation on the Internet (at www.phrusa.org),
including a comprehensive document, Break Them Down: Systematic Use
Of
Psychological Torture by US Forces (May 2005). A particular focus
of the
PHR is the deadly practices of U.S. imperialism’s Dr. Mengeles,
sadistic
doctors who participate in the torture, providing medical data to
interrogators, force-feeding prisoners, injecting them with
psychosis-inducing
drugs, tormenting them in psychotherapy sessions. Doctors who do not
cooperate
are reprimanded or reassigned. PHR wants to bar the torture docs from
practicing medicine, which is the least of what should happen to them.
The
Center for Constitutional Rights has published a hair-raising account
of U.S.
barbarism, Detention in Afghanistan and Guantánamo Bay,
by three young
torture camp survivors, Shafiq Rasul, Asif Iqbal, and Rhuhel Ahmed, who
managed
to get out due to their British citizenship (available on the CCR Web
site,
www.ccr-ny.org). Guards
terrify prisoner at Abu Ghraib with dog. The CCR
has led the effort to gain access to the
Guantánamo prisoners and challenge the government’s claim it can
with total
impunity indefinitely imprison anyone anywhere in the world it calls an
“enemy
combatant.” The U.S. says there are about 500 prisoners left at
“Gitmo,” mainly
Muslim citizens of so-called Third World countries, many of whom have
been
living in that nightmare for four years. Tormented beyond endurance,
with no
hope of getting out, they have found the strength to resist, resorting
to an
act of desperation out of necessity. Gutierrez reported that in the
hunger
strike against the abominable conditions at Guantánamo, an
estimated 200
prisoners may be near death. The present strike is a direct
continuation of the
preceding one, earlier this summer, which was called off after the
jailers
ostensibly granted some concessions. However, no concessions were ever
made.
Instead, once the strikers were eating again, they were subjected to
even worse
treatment than before. Many current hunger strikers have been force-fed
through
tubes forced down their noses. James
Yee also recounted his story to the New York
audience. While at Guantánamo and in his role as Muslim
chaplain, Yee was told
by prisoners that they lived in constant fear, under a regime of
psychological
and physical torture, preyed upon by sadistic guards, interrogators,
and
doctors. Yee, pretty much a straitlaced military man, passed on
prisoners’
complaints to his superior officer. The Army retaliated against him,
attempting
to frame him up as an “Al Qaeda” operative. In September 2003 he was
given
“leave” and then seized; taken to Jacksonville Naval Air Station, he
was
subjected to the same kind of sensory deprivation the government
practices on
Guantánamo prisoners. He was eventually dumped in a maximum
security military
prison in South Carolina, where he was kept in solitary confinement for
76
days. At first, Yee’s Syrian wife and his children were told nothing
and were
frantic about his whereabouts. When U.S. agents finally told Mrs. Yee
that her
husband was in prison, they treated her like a criminal too, and tried
to turn
her against him by lying about her husband having sex with coworkers. Court
papers were filed indicating that Yee would face
charges of “espionage, spying, aiding the enemy, mutiny or sedition,
and
disobeying an order. His attorneys were told that he could face
execution” (USA
Today, 16 May 2004). Pro-war mass media then went into action, with
the
fanatical right-wing Washington Times leading the way, accusing
Yee of
treason. The case against him, however, was a pack of lies, so the
government
quickly moved to Plan B, charging Yee with an absurd grab-bag of minor
infractions – from mishandling a classified document to more
far-fetched
fabrications involving “adultery” and “possession of pornography.”
(This
obsession with inflicting sexual humiliation on its victims runs
through the
entire repressive apparatus of the U.S. government to an extent
suggesting that
its bureaucracies are led by some serious psychos.) Once the paltry
charges
were made public, it was clear that the government had nothing – they
were
eventually dropped for lack of eveidence. Yee still had to fight a long
battle
to expunge Army lies from his record and secure an honorable discharge
– which
he did. The
Center for Constitutional Rights has won a number
of small victories recently, including getting the Pentagon to release
hundreds
more photos of the atrocities at Abu Ghraib, and challenging the
Homeland
Security prison in Brooklyn, where hundreds of Arabs were thrown in an
outrageous racist roundup in the aftermath of 9/11. It has also secured
lawyers
for many Guantánamo prisoners and has filed habeas corpus
petitions for 230 of
them. The government has fought them every step of the way. The habeas
corpus petitions,
for example, may have to go to the Supreme Court, which could take
years and
would be unbearable for the prisoners. The military have gone to great
lengths
deprive their prisoners of any legal protection. Interrogators imitate
lawyers,
sometimes for weeks, speaking abusively to prisoners, then show up in
military
dress, to sow confusion and mistrust of lawyers. Prisoners who have
legitimate
lawyers are told, “Your lawyer is a Jew. He doesn’t care about you!”
Prisoners
report that after the lawyer leaves, they are beaten. And, as Gutierrez
pointed
out, Guantánamo is the easiest site to visit. Thousands are
being held in total
isolation in even more remote or completely secret locations. As
Marxists we support efforts to gain legal
protection for the victims of U.S. imperialism. But we warn that there
is no
justice for the oppressed in the capitalist injustice system.
When the
CCR sued for the right of Guantánamo prisoners to have U.S.
court hearings, and
received a favorable (but vague) ruling from the Supreme Court under
right-wing
chief justice Rehnquist, (Rasul v. Bush, June 2004), the
government
simply ignored it. Even if the “detainees” had their “day in court,”
this is no
guarantee that they would get fair treatment. On the contrary, the
courts have
upheld the president’s right to arbitrarily declare individuals “enemy
combatants” without any proof at all. Last week, the U.S. Senate
attached a
rider to a military appropriations bill supposedly banning inhumane and
degrading treatment of prisoners. Not only will this be knocked out in
conference with the House of Representatives, or vetoed by the White
House,
even if passed and signed into law it would not stop this regime whose
whole
purpose is to terrorize the world into submission. Even
where “human rights” groups are not simply
stalking horses for a wing of the imperialists (such as the Zionist
Human
Rights Watch and the British Amnesty International who beat the drums
for war
on Yugoslavia), they at most seek to clean up imperialism’s act and
give it a
more humane face. The CCR calls to pressure Democrats like New York
senators
Charles Schumer and Hillary Clinton. Yet these capitalist politicians
wholeheartedly support the U.S.’ “war on terror,” of which the torture
prisons
are an integral part, accusing Bush & Co. of waging this
imperialist war
incompetently. From Afghanistan and Iraq today back to the U.S. and
French in
Vietnam and Algeria, and further back to the bloody U.S. takeover of
the
Philippines and the genocidal conquest of the Congo by Belgium (which
has the
gall to arrest African tyrants for crimes against humanity) at the turn
of the
last century, colonial wars are always accompanied hideous
torture and
wanton slaughter. The source of these horrors is the capitalist system
itself,
which generates endless war, poverty and racist oppression, and must be
overthrown. In
calling to “drive out the Bush regime,” as various
pseudo-socialist reformists (such as the Maoist RCP and the Stalinoid
WWP) do,
they are giving back-handed support to the Democrats, who launched the
Bay of
Pigs invasion of Cuba and the war on Vietnam. The Internationalist
Group fights
instead to drive out all the racist capitalist politicians (Democrats
and
Republicans alike, as well as minor league bourgeois pols like
immigrant basher
Ralph Nader) and build a revolutionary workers party. As they were
going to the
gallows in 1927, the Italian anarchist workers Sacco and Vanzetti, who
were
murdered by the capitalist state, said to their hundreds of thousands
of
supporters around the world, La salute è in voi
(Redemption is up to
you). Only through international socialist revolution will the heinous
war
criminals from Bush and Rumsfeld on down meet the fate the fate they
deserve
and rid this world of oppression once and for all. n To contact the Internationalist Group and the League for the Fourth International, send e-mail to: internationalistgroup@msn.com |
|